Columbian Home Granite Ware 18-Inch Covered Oval Roaster Product Review

0
174
roasting pans

The Columbian Home Granite Ware 18-Inch Covered Oval Roaster is a very popular roaster.  I've taken a close look at it and will share here the fine details of this roaster and what others are saying about it.  

Best Features of The Product 

  • Durable product
  • Dishwasher safe
  • Nice size
Sale
Granite Ware 18-Inch Covered Oval Roaster
  • Granite Ware Roaster is Made in USA
  • Hold up to 15 lbs poultry with the lid on and up to 18 lbs with the lid off
  • Porcelain enamel surface is an inert, non-porous and naturally non-stick surface

Most Talked About Features:

As of this writing there were 1,156 customer comments and 140 customer questions left on Amazon for the Columbian Home Granite Ware 18-Inch Covered Oval Roaster.  Just the number alone reflects that this is a popular roaster.  I've read through the feedback left on Amazon and then condensed the results into this article.  I hope that this helps you when picking out a roasting pan.

About The Material that The Pan Is Made From

roasting pans, roasting pan, turkey roasting pan, roasting pan with rack, pan roasted bussel sprouts, pan roasted chicken, electric roasting pan, shallow roasting pan, roasting pan walmart, roasting pan amazon, what is a roasting pan, pan roast, roasting pan with lid, all clad roasting pan, roasting pans, best roasting pan, stainless steel roasting pan, large roasting pan, roast pan, small roasting pan, pan roasted vegetables, target roasting pan, cast iron roasting pan, aluminum roasting pan, extra large roasting pan, best turkey roasting pan, disposable roasting pan, covered roasting pan

The Columbian Home Granite Ware 18-Inch Covered Oval Roaster is made from steel and porcelain.  The body is made from strong carbon steel for absorbing and distributing heat evenly and quickly.  Porcelain is then fused to the steel at 2,000 degrees Fahrenheit to produce a non-porous, inert glass surface that is naturally non-stick.  Though porcelain can chip if dropped, this doesn't reduce how effective this cookware is.  This porcelain on steel is good for metal utensils.  It is easy to clean and also dishwasher safe.  The dark surface absorbs the oven's energy and lowers cooking times.  The non-reactive finish won't absorb food flavors or change the color or taste of the food.  The dimpled lid bastes food making them moist.

Size

roasting pans, roasting pan, turkey roasting pan, roasting pan with rack, pan roasted bussel sprouts, pan roasted chicken, electric roasting pan, shallow roasting pan, roasting pan walmart, roasting pan amazon, what is a roasting pan, pan roast, roasting pan with lid, all clad roasting pan, roasting pans, best roasting pan, stainless steel roasting pan, large roasting pan, roast pan, small roasting pan, pan roasted vegetables, target roasting pan, cast iron roasting pan, aluminum roasting pan, extra large roasting pan, best turkey roasting pan, disposable roasting pan, covered roasting pan

This roaster has a 9 quart capacity and can hold up to 15 pounds of meat such as a turkey with the lid on.  With the lid off, it can hold up to 18 pounds.  The exterior dimensions with the lid are 17 15/16 x 12 ¼ x 7 5/8 inches.  The interior dimensions are 15 x 10 15/16 x 6 ¾ inches.  There are also side handles on this roaster for easy lifting and moving.

Dishwasher safe

roasting pans, roasting pan, turkey roasting pan, roasting pan with rack, pan roasted bussel sprouts, pan roasted chicken, electric roasting pan, shallow roasting pan, roasting pan walmart, roasting pan amazon, what is a roasting pan, pan roast, roasting pan with lid, all clad roasting pan, roasting pans, best roasting pan, stainless steel roasting pan, large roasting pan, roast pan, small roasting pan, pan roasted vegetables, target roasting pan, cast iron roasting pan, aluminum roasting pan, extra large roasting pan, best turkey roasting pan, disposable roasting pan, covered roasting pan

In addition to hand washing, the Columbian Home Granite Ware 18-Inch Covered Oval Roaster is also dishwasher safe for easy clean up.  The steel and porcelain together will not be harmed by the dishwasher.  This is definitely a big advantage for those who own a dishwasher.

No Rack Included

roasting pans, roasting pan, turkey roasting pan, roasting pan with rack, pan roasted bussel sprouts, pan roasted chicken, electric roasting pan, shallow roasting pan, roasting pan walmart, roasting pan amazon, what is a roasting pan, pan roast, roasting pan with lid, all clad roasting pan, roasting pans, best roasting pan, stainless steel roasting pan, large roasting pan, roast pan, small roasting pan, pan roasted vegetables, target roasting pan, cast iron roasting pan, aluminum roasting pan, extra large roasting pan, best turkey roasting pan, disposable roasting pan, covered roasting pan

While some roasters do come with a rack, the Columbian Home Granite Ware 18-Inch Covered Oval Roaster does not.  This is good to keep in mind when comparing prices.  

Not All Lids Fit On Perfectly

roasting pans, roasting pan, turkey roasting pan, roasting pan with rack, pan roasted bussel sprouts, pan roasted chicken, electric roasting pan, shallow roasting pan, roasting pan walmart, roasting pan amazon, what is a roasting pan, pan roast, roasting pan with lid, all clad roasting pan, roasting pans, best roasting pan, stainless steel roasting pan, large roasting pan, roast pan, small roasting pan, pan roasted vegetables, target roasting pan, cast iron roasting pan, aluminum roasting pan, extra large roasting pan, best turkey roasting pan, disposable roasting pan, covered roasting pan

A complaint that was not common, but was reoccurring enough to mention, was that some customers felt that their lids did not fit on evenly.  Some believe that it may have been dented or lost its shape in shipping, while others felt it had a manufactured flaw.  A small percent also said that the lids were sharp in places and to be careful when washing so that you don't cut your hands.

Handle Size

roasting pans, roasting pan, turkey roasting pan, roasting pan with rack, pan roasted bussel sprouts, pan roasted chicken, electric roasting pan, shallow roasting pan, roasting pan walmart, roasting pan amazon, what is a roasting pan, pan roast, roasting pan with lid, all clad roasting pan, roasting pans, best roasting pan, stainless steel roasting pan, large roasting pan, roast pan, small roasting pan, pan roasted vegetables, target roasting pan, cast iron roasting pan, aluminum roasting pan, extra large roasting pan, best turkey roasting pan, disposable roasting pan, covered roasting pan

Some customers wished the handles were made just a little bit bigger for ease of lifting. Others felt that the handles were not heavy duty enough and could fall off when lifting roasters that were carrying a lot of weight.  I did not, however, find anyone who said the handles of the Columbian Home Granite Ware 18-Inch Covered Oval Roaster fell off.

Can Withstand High Heat

roasting pans, roasting pan, turkey roasting pan, roasting pan with rack, pan roasted bussel sprouts, pan roasted chicken, electric roasting pan, shallow roasting pan, roasting pan walmart, roasting pan amazon, what is a roasting pan, pan roast, roasting pan with lid, all clad roasting pan, roasting pans, best roasting pan, stainless steel roasting pan, large roasting pan, roast pan, small roasting pan, pan roasted vegetables, target roasting pan, cast iron roasting pan, aluminum roasting pan, extra large roasting pan, best turkey roasting pan, disposable roasting pan, covered roasting pan

People liked that this roaster held up fine in high heat.  It was common for customers to have food cooking for a long length of time at 450 degrees Fahrenheit.  The Columbian Home Granite Ware 18-Inch Covered Oval Roaster held up just find with no warping or discoloration.

Not Just For Roasting

roasting pans, roasting pan, turkey roasting pan, roasting pan with rack, pan roasted bussel sprouts, pan roasted chicken, electric roasting pan, shallow roasting pan, roasting pan walmart, roasting pan amazon, what is a roasting pan, pan roast, roasting pan with lid, all clad roasting pan, roasting pans, best roasting pan, stainless steel roasting pan, large roasting pan, roast pan, small roasting pan, pan roasted vegetables, target roasting pan, cast iron roasting pan, aluminum roasting pan, extra large roasting pan, best turkey roasting pan, disposable roasting pan, covered roasting pan

Some people who bought this roaster liked to put it on the stove and have two burners going under it to cook up dishes like kielbasa and vegetables.  This roaster can be used basically like a big stove top pan in addition to a roaster for the oven.

Does It Really Fit A 15 Pound Turkey?  Some Customers Say "No"

roasting pans, roasting pan, turkey roasting pan, roasting pan with rack, pan roasted bussel sprouts, pan roasted chicken, electric roasting pan, shallow roasting pan, roasting pan walmart, roasting pan amazon, what is a roasting pan, pan roast, roasting pan with lid, all clad roasting pan, roasting pans, best roasting pan, stainless steel roasting pan, large roasting pan, roast pan, small roasting pan, pan roasted vegetables, target roasting pan, cast iron roasting pan, aluminum roasting pan, extra large roasting pan, best turkey roasting pan, disposable roasting pan, covered roasting pan

I've found some discrepancy as to how big of a turkey will really fit in the Columbian Home Granite Ware 18-Inch Covered Oval Roaster.  Though it is advertised as being able to fit a 15 pound turkey with the lid on, some customers disagreed.  Most people felt that it could fit a 10-12 pound turkey with the lid on and a 13-14  pound turkey with the lid off.  

About the Company

roasting pans, roasting pan, turkey roasting pan, roasting pan with rack, pan roasted bussel sprouts, pan roasted chicken, electric roasting pan, shallow roasting pan, roasting pan walmart, roasting pan amazon, what is a roasting pan, pan roast, roasting pan with lid, all clad roasting pan, roasting pans, best roasting pan, stainless steel roasting pan, large roasting pan, roast pan, small roasting pan, pan roasted vegetables, target roasting pan, cast iron roasting pan, aluminum roasting pan, extra large roasting pan, best turkey roasting pan, disposable roasting pan, covered roasting pan

The Columbian Home Products company has been around for a long time.  I don't know about you, but I feel better about buying from an established company than a new company.  Founded in 1871, the Columbian Home Products is the oldest cookware manufacturer in the United States.  The company is famous for producing porcelain on steel cookware.  They have been producing Granite Ware cookware in Terre Haute in their facility since 1901.  Their products are all made in the USA.

My Conclusion 

The Columbian Home Granite Ware 18-Inch Covered Oval Roaster is a popular roaster.  It's a versatile roaster that can be used for roasting and for stove top cooking.  It is dishwasher safe and cleans up well.  The porcelain and steel together make this a durable and sturdy pan.  Some customers, however, felt like the handles could have been made bigger for ease of picking up a filled roaster.  There was some discrepancy of how much poundage this roaster can handle. While it is advertised as being able to cook a 15 pound turkey with the lid on, some people found that it could only cook a 10-12 pound turkey with the lid on and 13-14 pound turkey with the lid off.  The Columbian Home Products Company has been around since 1871 making cookware products.  I would feel confident buying this roaster from this well known and established company.

For more reviews and information, check our out Top Ten Roasting Pans of 2018.

LEAVE A REPLY

Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.